We believe in simplicity when it comes to BBQ. One of the tricks with brisket is that people often think they have over-cooked it when, in fact, they have under-cooked it. This is why using a meat thermometer, instead of time alone, is so important. All meat temperatures noted are from the thickest part of the brisket.
This method uses two stages of cooking. We use a smoker temperature between 225°F and 250°F throughout, however you can use higher temps (especially for the second stage). Note this method will result in a dark but softer bark.
We use a “packer-cut” brisket which will have both the “point” and the “flat” sections and likely be between 12 and 16 pounds. For smaller pieces found in most butcher counters you will likely only get the “flat” portion. We find using Choice (preferably Certified Black Angus) to provide good consistent tenderness. When in doubt ask your butcher about the cut and grade!
The night before:
- Trim the brisket to roughly 1/4″ fat.
- Season with rub of choice. We put the rub right on the meat. Just season, do not create heavy packed layers of rub on the meat.
The day of:
- Preheat smoker to desired range (we use 225°F – 250°F).
- Add smoke wood (2-3 chunks, unsoaked) into the coals. Follow your smoker’s direction for proper indirect setup.
- Place meat in the smoker.
- Smoke until meat temperature reads between 170°F and 185°F it will take considerable hours just to get to this point. Also note that this 15 degree range is a VERY large range that can span hours so don’t feel like you have to monitor your smoker on a minute-by-minute basis.
- Place the brisket in foil or peach paper and add 1-2 cups of quality beef stock that has been preheated.
- Place wrapped meat with stock back onto the smoker and cook until meat reads 200°F.
- Move unopened, wrapped meat to a clean, empty, room-temperature portable cooler. Rest for 1-3 hours.
- Slice against the grain. Remember that the “point” section of a packer-cut brisket will have two grains so we do recommend separating the top part of the point from the bottom (which is actually the extension of the flat).
- Use the “au jus” from the wrapping to keep the brisket moist; supplement with warm beef stock if need be.